Saturday, March 2, 2013

The Times, it is Outragin’


We’ve never settled the question of just what science in anthropology actually is.  I don’t think anybody is against it, but the problem is that the people who have always claimed most self-consciously to speak for it have an absolutely awful track record.

We can start with Ernst Haeckel, great German biologist.  Haeckel had such a hard-on for Darwin that he believed Darwinism would produce ‘‘an important and fruitful reform of anthropology. From this new theory of man, there will be developed a new philosophy, not like most of the airy systems of metaphysical speculation hitherto prevalent, but one founded upon the solid ground of comparative zoology.’’

Problem was that Haeckel’s Darwinism incorporated the idea that life progressed from amoebas to the Nordic military state, and he saw other human populations as different species, occupying places at varying distances from the apes.  In a nutshell, Haeckel’s “solid ground” eventually produced the worst anthropology our science has ever known.  Josef Mengele, the Auschwitz camp doctor, was an MD/PhD.  His doctorate was in scientific anthropology.

Yes, mistakes were made in the name of scientific anthropology.  People were objectified, robbed of their humanity, because anthropologists wanted to be scientists, like biologists.  The problem is that biologists have an advantage, in that they have established an intellectual distance between themselves and the things they study – subject/object, scientist/fruitfly.  But anthropologists don’t study things, they study people (or animals very much like people).

To regard people as if they were not people is objectification.  It is repugnant in modern cultural life, and it is a false proposition as science, because, in a nutshell, people really are people.  So, as a scientist working on people, you have three choices.  Either you can pretend that they’re not people (evil), or you can pretend that you are not a person (stupid), or you can acknowledge that the classic subject/object distinction that is fundamental to classical science simply breaks down here.  That is eventually what Martin Arrowsmith realized (medical researcher, not an anthropologist, but the point holds) in the famous 1925 novel by Sinclair Lewis.  You can’t pretend you are not human, and you can’t pretend they are not human, but somehow you still have to do your scientific work as rigorously as possible, confronting the culture in your science as fairly as possible.  This science is reflexive.

By breaking down the subject/object distinction, this science assumes a position not only in the natural universe but in the moral universe as well.  Its founder, the Quaker Oxford professor E. B. Tylor, wrote at the end of Primitive Culture (1871) that this is “a reformer’s science.”  Its statements have political valence, and to say that they don’t is itself a statement of political valence.  

Mistakes were made.  Franz Boas made them, trying to be scientific about the New York Eskimos around 1900.   The eugenicists made them, the scientific racists made them.  We all make them.  The point about science is that it progresses on the basis of previous mistakes.  But you don’t get to make the same mistakes over and over in science; you only get to make new and creative mistakes. 

That’s the problem with the newest flareup about science in anthropology and the Yanomamo.  Mistakes were made.  We’ve learned from them and we’ve moved on.  So why haven’t Napoleon Chagnon and The New York Times?  Why are they frozen in ideas about anthropological science from the 1970s?  Why does Napoleon Chagnon compare himself to Indiana Jones, in the very first paragraph of Emily Eakin’s New York Times article?  Does he not realize that it’s not a compliment in this day and age?  Indiana Jones was a looter, and archaeologists vigorously protested the representation of their field in the first movie. 

Why does Nicholas Wade say, lauding Chagnon, that the Yanomamo live “in a state of nature”?  Twice?  Using steel axes and practicing horticulture is not a state of nature.  (Hugh Gusterson of George Mason University pointed this out in a letter.)  They are cultural, very cultural, as cultural as you and me. 

Remember, though, that Nicholas Wade is on record as an anthropology-denier.  In an interview with the Anthropology News in 2007, he told them , "Anyone who’s interested in cultural anthropology should escape as quickly as they can from their cultural anthropology department and go and learn some genetics, which will be the foundation of cultural anthropology in the future."

The first thing about being a scientist is to get your facts straight.  The imaginary “man” who lived in a “state of nature” was a common enough theme in the French Enlightenment, but it was recognized as a pre-modern myth by the turn of the twentieth century.  All cultures are cultural.  All groups of people regulate social interactions, communicate symbolically, cook, prettify themselves, and transform intrinsically useless natural objects into useful cultural ones.  (As Jane Goodall showed decades ago, even chimps do a little of that.) 

And people have been doing those things since before they were people.  All living people are in a state of nature/culture.  Nobody is in a state of nature.  In fact we don’t even know what such a state of pure nature would be like, because it contains an inherent contradiction – trying to imagine people who aren’t people.

There are all kinds of issues entangled in the Yanomamo business: research ethics; a bizarre book published in 2000, abstracted first in The New Yorker, called Darkness in El Dorado; sociobiology; the intersection of science and political ideology; and the welfare of indigenous peoples.  I am going to focus on two issues: first, the claim that empirically Napoleon Chagnon linked murder with reproductive success among the Yanomamo, and that the linkage is generalizable; and second, that the claim was rejected by the anthropological community for ideological reasons, involving the rejection of science itself.  The New York Times has articulated these claims uncritically several times in the last few weeks; but both are false, and the second one in particular is pernicious.

Can we generalize from Napoleon Chagnon’s demonstration that murder and babies are correlated?

Second part first.  What would it mean if Yanomamo murderers outbred non-murderers?  Well, if you believe that this is a bi-allelic system, then the Yanomamo murderer alleles would quickly swamp out the non-murderer alleles.  But of course only a fucking idiot would believe that.  If you believe that the genetic differences between murderers and non-murderers are random, then the Yanomamo might have a trivial bit of transient microevolutionary things going on.  But if the reproductive bias isn’t consistent over generations, it would have no significant microevolutionary effect at all. 

Yet obviously we are not talking about multi-generational data here, simply a snapshot of one point in time.  So even on its best day, these data could not testify to the microevolutionary activity of selection.  It could simply be a blip in Yanomamo demography.

And can we actually say with certainty that the relationship between killers and babies held for those people at that time?  In the journal American Ethologist in 1989, Brian Ferguson pointed out that Chagnon’s data are incomplete, because he did not present data on the reproduction of killers who had themselves been killed.   This is important to someone who thinks deeply about evolution, because killing is risky, and if the reproductive bias is offset by a mortality bias, then there would be no net evolutionary effect.   Chagnon was not able to present these data, but waved his hands when a journalist for Science magazine wrote it up over a decade ago

But, Chagnon told Science, he “didn't record at the time the status of unokai men who were killed,” which is necessary to respond to Ferguson .... “But from what I know,” he says, “it looks as though [Ferguson's] hypothesis doesn't hold up.”

No, Chagnon is the one with a hypothesis, and his data are statistically inadequate to either confirm or deny it.  Moreover, when Nicholas Wade writes, “Dr. Chagnon said he was familiar with those criticisms but called them invalid and said none had been published in a peer-reviewed journal”  he puts an unchallenged falsehood in Chagnon’s mouth in support of this poor scientific reasoning.

Further, from an analysis of the data Chagnon presented, Douglas Fry was able to find an apparent 10-year average difference between the killers and the non-killers.  Of course the older sample are going to have more children than the younger sample, duh.  If Chagnon didn’t control for age, then any reproductive contrast between killers and non-killers is meaningless.  As Miklikowska and Fry document in a recent article, all Chagnon could do was deny that it was true, but he never produced the data to show it.  In science, if you make a claim, you have to demonstrate its validity and do the proper controls.  Or else shut up.  Really.

That’s not an extravagant demand; it is an expectation.  Back when I was a post-doc in molecular genetics in the 1980s, and we were studying the best-known part of the human genome at the time, the hemoglobin genes, we claimed to have found a hitherto unknown hemoglobin gene.  It was a pretty bold claim.  And by golly, we had to produce all of our evidence and show that we had done all the proper controls, and that our conclusion was the only reasonable conclusion to be drawn from the data, before Nature would publish it.  If Napoleon Chagnon wants to be judged by the standards of good science, those are the standards his claim has to face; and it fails miserably.

Now the first part.  What on earth is the basis for thinking that any pattern found among the Yanomamo a generation ago, unless you are yourself a Yanomamo, can be reasonably understood as a surrogate for your own ancestors?  In order to generalize like that, you would have to cast the Yanomamo adrift from global geopolitics, pretend that that they are ahistorical, and use these modern South American horticulturalists as metaphorical stand-ins for Upper Pleistocene hunter-gatherers.  In short, that would be a pre-modern and incompetent form of anthropological reasoning.

Nicholas Wade, a tireless supporter of Chagnon’s in The New York Times, explains that “he seemed to be saying that aggression was rewarded and could be inherited.”  Saying that is permissible, but deriving it from this dataset is incompetent.   Elsewhere Chagnon’s work has been brandished not so much as Wade sees it, supporting genetic diversity (killers versus non-killers), but in support of genetic uniformity (the Yanomamo represent an “acting out” of the basic human nature that we all share).  But if human biology is a constant, then it is not explanatory.  You can’t use a constant to explain a variable in science.  Why would the Yanomamo be acting it out and not the Danes?  Could  it be for historical and political reasons?

There may certainly be generalizations to be made about the common form of social life of early people from the ethnographic observation of contemporary hunter-gatherers, but those generalizations are very broad and non-specific, because they have to incorporate the particular histories and local ecologies of the people being studied.  After all, people act not simply as humans, but as humans of a particular time and place and life experiences (we tend to call that culture).  Consequently, we are far more circumspect today about de-historicizing the !Kung San (everybody’s favorite hunter-gatherers, in southern Africa) than we were a few decades ago.  And that is why we understand the Yanomamo and what they do as products of history and politics, because there certainly is a lot of history and politics going on to affect their behavior.  Anyone who wants to argue that the behavior they observe in anybody has no historical origin or political context, but is a dislocated manifestation of an uncultural human nature, will not be taken seriously by a community of scholars of human behavior, unless they can really unambiguously prove their point.

To recap:
  • ·       Chagnon’s data do not warrant the conclusion that Yanomamo killers statistically out-bred non-killers.
  • ·       If a statistical relationship were there, as a synchronic datum it would not warrant the conclusion that it is of evolutionary relevance in Yanomamo society.
  • ·       If it were of evolutionary relevance in Yanomamo society, it would not warrant the conclusion that it is applicable to early Holocene societies of Asians, Africans, Europeans, Oceanics, North Americans, or other South Americans.
  • ·       Consequently, anyone who argues from Chagnon’s data to early Holocene human societies is not showing evidence of intellectual competence in this area.


Was Chagnon’s work rejected out of an anti-science ideological bias in anthropology?

Are you fucking kidding me?  Say that out loud and hear how stupid it sounds.

Nicholas Wade explains it to us.  “In 2010 the A.A.A. voted to strip the word ‘science’ from its long-range mission plan and focus instead on ‘public understanding.’  Its distaste for science and its attack on Dr. Chagnon are now an indelible part of its record.”  That is pretty much true, except for the omission of one word:  “not”.  The AAA voted not to strip the word “science” from its long range plan.  Yes, it was suggested (to emphasize the breadth of the scope of anthropology beyond the boundaries of science and encompassing the humanities as well); yes, it was put to a vote (because there was some feeling that it was a bad idea); and yes, it was voted down.   That’s quite a slander against anthropology from The New York Times

In fact, the suggestion that anthropology is under a delusional cloud is one that we are more accustomed to hearing from creationists and other anti-intellectuals.  For example, that’s not the first time those charges have appeared in print in The New York TimesIn a letter they published on October 24, 1962, two segregationists wrote that the “race-equality dogma” was part of a “socialistic ideology” promoted by a “cult” of anthropologists.   Except that the “cult” was actually the mainstream science of anthropology, and that claim was a highly political and anti-intellectual dissimulation.  It still is.

There has been an ideological war going on for a long time, between anthropological science and sociobiology-cum-evolutionary-psychology.  The problem is that anthropology has let the other side speak, largely unchallenged, on behalf of science.  So The New York Times tells us,

In his view, evolution and sociobiology, ...  it made perfect sense that the struggle among the Yanomamö, and probably among all human societies at such a stage in their history, was for reproductive advantage.

That’s an interesting ideological position, but it isn’t supported empirically, it ignores historical and political causes, and it no more represents evolutionary science than social darwinism or eugenics did.  We have been here before; douchebags are always recruiting Darwin to their stupid views about human society.  Frances Galton did; Ernst Haeckel did; Charles Davenport did; Georges Vacher de Lapouge did; Robert Ardrey did; the late Phil Rushton did; and Steven Pinker still does.

It’s not that the opposition is against Darwinism; it’s that Darwinism is compatible with many understandings of human social behavior, including normative anthropology.  Nicholas Wade scowls at Marshall Sahlins, who recently resigned from the National Academy of Sciences partly over Chagnon’s election, by explaining that Sahlins opposes sociobiology, which Wade defines as “the idea that human social behavior is shaped by evolution and culture.” 

Actually (as pointed out to me by Seth Dobson from Dartmouth), that’s not sociobiology, that’s anthropology!  How could you possibly beat up Sahlins as a denier of evolution and culture when he actually once co-edited a book called Evolution and Culture?

Here’s something Wade actually gets right:  The two men have been at odds for decades over the validity of sociobiology”.  But nobody –  not even sociobiologists – still believe what they were saying back in the late 1970s, when they initially chose to position themselves against anthropology.  Richard Dawkins casually explained at the end of The Selfish Gene that human behavior was not bound by the dictates of genetic maximization principles because the spread of imaginary cultural “memes” could  oppose and overwhelm the imaginary genetic propensities he had been writing about.   Various second-wave sociobiologists have picked up on that, but the theory that humans maximize their memetic fitness is essentially a cultural alternative to the idea that humans maximize their genetic fitness.  Which means that you can’t assume humans are maximizing their genetic fitness, which means that the central tenet of sociobiology – that an “evolutionary” explanation of human behavior begins with the assumption that human behavior is intended to maximize genetic fitness – is wrong.  E. O. Wilson now believes in group selection.  And as Sahlins pointed out years ago, in order for kin selection to explain human behavior, human societies would have to define kin in approximately the same way that nature does – and they don’t. 

[Of that book, The Use and Abuse of Biology, Chagnon says, “he had published his Use and Abuse of Biology in 1976, which should have made clear to the members of the NAS how antiscientific Sahlins was."  A clearer-headed thinker might imagine that distinguishing use from abuse is crucial to science, and that the reluctance or inability to distinguish between them might reasonably constitute the opposite of a good science education.]

It’s not that anthropology is against evolution, it’s that anthropology is against the perversion of evolution in support of idiosyncratic social theories, which recurs every generation.  Here is Franz Boas, over a century ago, reflecting on the influence of Darwinism on first-generation anthropology of the 19th century:

All sciences were equally guilty of premature theories of evolution based on observed homologies and supposed similarities. The theories had to be revised again and again, as the slow progress of empirical knowledge of the data of evolution proved their fallacy.

And this was before the eugenicists, much less the sociobiologists.  And before you call Boas anti-science, let me remind you that he was a President of the American Association for the Advancement of Science  in 1931-1932.  There he is now, accepting the  presidency of the AAAS from his predecessor, the geneticist Thomas Hunt Morgan, who worked in the same building at Columbia as Boas for many years.  Morgan never called Boas anti-science; the eugenicists did. 
              
The other anthropologist who presided over the AAAS in the 20th century is also the other one that sociobiologists try to discredit: Margaret Mead.  [That’s kind of ironic, isn’t it?  The two anthropologists whom sociobiologists are most keen to discredit as being anti-science, were both Presidents of the American Association for the Advancement of Science.]  After her death she was hounded by a sociobiologist nutter named Derek Freeman.  Freeman believed that Margaret Mead’s 1928 book, Coming of Age in Samoa, was false, for she had been hoaxed, which in turn undermined all of the rest of her life’s work and indeed all 20th century anthropology, and thus proved sociobiology to be right.  The sociobiologists regularly cite that, including the entire stream of illogical consequences, quite uncritically.  In fact, even Emily Eakin repeated it in The New York Times in her story on Chagnon.

In 1983, the New Zealand anthropologist Derek Freeman delivered a major blow when he published “Margaret Mead and Samoa,” charging that Mead had been duped by informants in her pioneering ethnography, “Coming of Age in Samoa.”

Only problem is that Freeman’s charges have been scrutinized very, very carefully and comprehensively shown to be false.  Even Freeman’s “smoking gun” – the eyewitness testimony of Fa’apua’a saying she lied to Margaret Mead, has now been shown to be complete rubbish.  Alice Dreger, a supporter of Chagnon, acknowledges the sociobiological slander against Mead in her blog.

Actually The New York Times has repeated Derek Freeman’s charges over a half-dozen times since 1983, most recently (before Eakin’s article on Chagnon) in Freeman’s 2001 obituary.  The only time they’ve told readers that his charges were, as far as anybody could tell, total bullshit – was in a letter published in response to the Freeman obit, by the  AAA President, Louise Lamphere.  She summarized tersely and politely:  “Most serious scholarship casts grave doubt on his data and theory.”

And yet, zombie Freeman is allowed to rise again in this article, in defense of Napoleon Chagnon, without any qualification whatsoever?  That might be a clue that this is a rhetorical and ideological battle, not an empirical scientific one.  Emily Eakin serves as a mouthpiece for Napoleon Chagnon without even acknowledging the problems with his work.  Nicholas Wade weighs in twice in the space of two weeks on Chagnon’s behalf, and discredits the science of anthropology.  As I noted in my last entry, his relevant book was judged to be social Darwinism by reviewers in Nature; I think he’s got a horse in this race.

To recap:

·     Science, evolution, and anthropology are all on the same side.  The other side is where the anti-intellectuals and ideologues are, and have always been, the ones who either don’t understand evolution themselves, or are knowingly misrepresenting its implications to the public.  As I said, that is a recurrent theme in the history of this intellectual engagement.

·     In fact, I’ll revise that thought: Science, evolution, anthropology, and history are all on the same side.

For The New York Times to promote Chagnon’s anti-intellectual nonsense unchallenged, as if it represented evolution, much less science, is a terrible, terrible mistake.  And for them to allow Nicholas Wade to conduct his intellectual war against the science of anthropology in their pages is outrageous.

23 comments:

  1. Thanks Jon. I especially appreciated your pointing out what a toady Wade is. Chagnon is the blithering idiot, but it takes real bastards like Wade to keep his idiocy alive.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Well well well. When asked in 1978-9 to challenge Wilson's Socio-biology from the perspective of assumptions about female subjugation as a function of genes and biology (shared by many anthropologists as well as an entemologist then, I asked "why are you asking me to Interrupt my I was sure groundbreaking work to beat an old Trojan horse back into its grave?". I did a pretty good job tho ((AAAS proceedings 1979) Wilson came to my campus to be feted by my president, nixon's secy of HEW. This was U of Ala. I invented calling vote of confidence by faculty in a univ pres. End of my and David Matthews (the Pres) academic lives. Sad to see Trojan horse up and galloping. I think more a reflection of current who thinks which way the Politcal financial wind is blowing funding than leaps of clarity in my absence. I always loved and still cite Sahlins whose letter re etymology of tribe (paid tribute to Rome) I found when Tapson Mwere, preparing to negotiate the end of Rhodesia for ZANU asked me to find out where the notion tribe "we didn't use before" came from

    ReplyDelete
  3. lol nice.

    Somebody already updated Wikipedia on the matter, tho quite shortly:
    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nicholas_Wade

    Hopefully more people will eventually realize how fucking dumb some science reporters/journalists tend to be.

    What's sad, is that Wade's book is the type of book that is picked up by uncritical and uninformed minds. Even in this day, normal people don't know what anthropology is or does -- and not even scholars by the looks of it!

    ReplyDelete
  4. I appreciate this nuanced discussion of the caricatures of multiple disciplines and their variants, including cultural and biological anthropology. I will be recommending this post for years to come!

    ReplyDelete
  5. You're an inspiration and a menace to douchebags everywhere! And I totally stole that pic of Boas and Morgan.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Blogged on the Chagnon issue(s) myself - you will find yourself both quoted and critiqued. comments welcome . . .

    http://embodiedknowledges.blogspot.co.uk/

    ReplyDelete
  7. Hey, check it out, more anti-anthropology crap:

    http://blogs.discovermagazine.com/gnxp/2013/02/against-the-cultural-anthropologists/#.UWiSc6Lvs6Z

    ReplyDelete
  8. Professor, you must look at this:

    http://www.guardian.co.uk/books/booksblog/2013/apr/25/richard-dawkins-named-top-thinker

    How would the anthropology community respond to that?

    ReplyDelete
  9. 5
    MEGLIO MORTI CHE ARRESI!
    CHE SIA 25 APRILE 1945 BIS!
    I NUOVI PARTIGIANI ( E NON CERTO, NAZIMAFIOSI KILLER "PAR-TEA"GIANI)!
    DA BRUXELLES, LONDON, RIO DE JANEIRO, MANAGUA (OVE TIFIAMO PER UN NUOVO VINCENTISSIMO CANALE OCEANO-PACIFICO "DI CENTRO-SINISTRA" PER SURCLUSSARE QUELLO MA-F-ASCISTA DI PANAMA DEI BASTARDI CRIMINALISSIMI VALTER LAVITOLA, RICARDO MARTINELLI, PAOLO BARRAI, SILVIO BERLUSCONI E NOTO AMBASCIATORE DI "COSA NOSTRA, CAMORRA E NDRANGHETA" GIANCARLO MARIA CURCIO http://www.globalist.it/Detail_News_Display?ID=2828), SAN JOSE DI COSTARICA, HABANA VIEJA, CARACAS ( OVE STIAMO PREPARANDO UN FORTISSIMO RECUPERO ECONOMICO E SOCIALE), ACCRA, JOHANNESBURG, PECHINO, TORONTO, NEW YORK ( QUELLA DEL GRANDISSIMO DEMOCRAT, PROSSIMAMENTE, US PRESIDENT: BILL DE BLASIO)!
    PS2
    E CHE SIA CHIARO, IO NON SON PER NULLA GENIO, RE MIDA ED EROE CIVILE MICHELE NISTA. NON LO SONO, ANCHE SE LO VORREI DI CERTO ESSERE, VISTO IL SUO ECCEZIONALE GENIO E FIUTO. DA ASSOLUTI NUMERI UNO AL MONDO. E CHE VEDREI BENISSIMO SULLA SEGGIOLA DI STO CESSO NAZISTA E NDRANGHETISTA DI MATTEO RENZI, CORROTTISSIMO DA SILVIO BERLUSCONI, PER FARE LEGGI, E PRENDERE DECISIONI, PRO, QUEST‘ULTIMA „FASCIOCAMORRISTAM ED PEDOFILAM PERSONAM“. DA POSIZIONE DI FINTISSIMO CENTRO SINISTRA, CHE E‘ ORMAI, IN REALTA‘, ESTREMISSIMA DESTRA. CERCANDO COSI‘ DI FREGARE TUTTI ( DA APPOSTAZIONE INASPETTATA)! SGOZZANDO A MORTE, DEMOCRAZIA, GIUSTIZIA, E LIBERTA‘. NON SONO GENIO, RE MIDA ED EROE CIVILE MICHELE NISTA, CHE, MAI DIMENTICHIAMOCI, PERO', OVUNQUE IN VITA SUA ABBIA MESSO LE MANI, HA SEMPRE, SEMPRE E STRA SEMPRE, RESO LE PIETRE, ORO. COME QUANDO CIRCA VENTENNE, PREVEDETTE E CON TRE MESI DI ANTICIPO IL MEGA CROLLO DEL DOW JONES DELL’OTTOBRE 1987. AVVENUTO POI PUNTUALISSIMAMENTE, FRA LO SHOCK DI TUTTI, IN BORSA, A MILANO, CHE LO INIZIARONO A CHIAMARE „IL PROFETA“ ( ED INTANTO SI STRAPPAVANO DALLE MANI, MICHELE STESSO, DA UN POSTO DI LAVORO ALL’ALTRO, IN QUANTO RENDEVA SEMPRE, DESKS CHE FACEVANO ZERO PROFITTI, MILIARDARIE, PUR SE IN LIRE, UN ANNO DOPO.. DA QUI IL PASSAGGIO DEL SUO NICK, COL TEMPO, DA „PROFETA“ A „RE MIDA“.. E SENZA MAI CHE GIOCASSE SPORCO, SENZA MAI CHE CORROMPESSE O ELUDESSE UNA LIRA, CHE UNA, DI TASSE). A SEGUIRE, MICHELE PREVEDETTE ALLA PERFEZIONE IL MEGA RIALZO DEL DOW JONES DELL’ERA BILL CLINTON, IL CROLLO DEL NASDAQ CON L’ARRIVO ABUSIVISSIMO, FIGLIO DI MEGA FRODI ELETTORALI, DI „ADOLF HITLER - GEORGE [WC] BUSH“. E SPECIALMENTE, QUI, ANTICIPANDO IL TUTTO VIA INTERNET, DAVANTI AGLI OCCHI DEL MONDO INTERO, MICHELE URLO‘ NEL SETTEMBRE 2007 CHE IL DOW JONES SAREBBE CROLLATO DA 13400 A 6900 ENTRO UN SOLO ANNO! TUTTI A DARGLI DEL MATTO, MA IL DOW JONES UN ANNO DOPO VALEVA ESATTAMENTE 6900! LI TUTTI A DARGLI DEL GENIO! COME PREVEDETTE ALLA PERFEZIONE IL PIU‘ CHE RADDOPPIO DEL DOW JONES NELL’ERA DELL’AMMIRABILE OBAMA BARACK ( RIALZO DA LUI PREVISTO, SEMPRE DAVANTI AGLI OCCHI DEL MONDO INTERO, DI NUOVO, VIA INTERNET, BEN SEI MESI PRIMA DI QUANDO INIZIO‘ A VERIFICARSI: DA LUI ANTICIPATO NEL OTTOBRE 2008, VERIFICATOSI NEL MARZO 2009, ESATTAMENTE, NEL PERIODO DA LUI PREVISTO SEI MESI PRIMA). E DA APRILE 2014, RIPETO, DA APRILE 2014, MICHELE HA DETTO A TUTTI „NOI“, CHE IL DOW JONES SAREBBE SALITO ANCORA, MA PER POI MINICROLLARE NELLA PARTE FINALE DEL LUGLIO 2014: ACCADUTO AL MILLESIMO. E „NOI“ SAPPIAMO GIA‘ ANCHE DOVE SARA‘ IL DOW JONES ALLE PROSSIME ELEZIONI USA DEL 2016. E SIAMO CERTI CHE SARA‘ ESATTISSIMAMENTE LI, OVE CE LO HA DETTO LUI: GENIO, RE MIDA ED EROE CIVILE MICHELE NISTA. CON LUI SI VINCE SEMPRE E STRA SEMPRE, ALTRO CHE POR-C-ORROTTO BERLUSCONICCHIO SGOZZA DEMOCRAZIA, GIUSTIZIA E LIBERTA‘, PROVETTO DITTATORE PAZZO: MATTEO RENZI. IL VERME RISDOGANATORE DEL BASTARDAMENTE ASSASSINO, BERLUSCONISMO, OSSIA MAFIA, CAMORRA, NDRANGHETA, FASCISMO E PEDOFILIA, A PALAZZO CHIGI! PUAH, CHE SCHIFO, IO ODIO RENZUSCONIA E NE SON ORGOGLIOSO! E' PIU' INFIMA E PERICOLOSA DI BERLUSCONIA E LO SUPER STRA VEDRETE! "SOON BACK"!!!

    ReplyDelete
  10. Awesome Post!
    Download Diwali Animated Gifs 2017
    Download Diwali Animated Gifs
    Download Diwali Gifs
    Also Read trending Story deep meaning comics
    Also Check out Latest Government Job of Haryana jobs

    ReplyDelete
  11. Vi segnaliamo che il vostro blog sta offrendo spazio e visibilità a un criminale di nome Michele Nista, i cui commenti diffamatori sono presenti in questo post/blog. Michele Nista, attraverso il furto di identità di decine di soggetti, conduce la propria attività criminale di cyber stalking internazionale di centinaia di persone, pubblicando decine di migliaia di commenti farneticanti su siti di tutto il mondo. Si tratta di soggetto pericoloso e sul quale stanno indagando diverse Procure italiane. Vi ricordiamo che la responsabilità per le diffamazioni presenti nei commenti del Vostro sito/blog sono anche a carico degli amministratori del sito. Pertanto il presente commento vale anche come diffida affinché provvediate a rimuovere tali contenuti e a prendere le opportune precauzioni affinché ciò non si verifichi più.
    Per ogni ulteriore informazione riguardante il soggetto in questione è possibile consultare https://fermiamolostalker.blogspot.it/

    ReplyDelete
  12. A)
    MICHELE NISTA E' UN GRANDISSIMO UOMO, A NETTA VOSTRA DIFFERENZA, NAZI-ST-ALKERS ASSASSINI DI AR-COR-LEONE, CHE BRAMATE TANTO DALLA VOGLIA DI RENDERLO NUOVO GIACOMO MATTEOTTI. MICHELE NISTA E' UN GRANDISSIMO UOMO. OLTRE CHE UN VINCENTISSIMO GENIO BORSISTICO CHE AZZECCA IN AZIONI, VALUTE, CRIPTOVALUTE, MATERIE PRIME, SEMPRE SEMPRE, STRA SEMPRE. DA VERO E PROPRIO RE MIDA ( LO SCRIVEVATE VOI STESSI FRA IL 2007 E 2010..
    http://michelenistacivilhero.blogspot.com.es/ )
    QUINDI, SAPETE TUTTO QUESTO ALLA PERFEZIONE..
    SCRIVEVATE TUTTO QUESTO VOI STESSI..QUANDO VI MEGA ARRICCHIVA CON LE SUE VINCENTISSIME PREVISIONI SU WALL STREET E TUTTI I LISTI AZIONARI DEL MONDO..PREVEDENDO CON MESI E MESI DI ANTICIPO, ED ALLA PERFEZIONE, LA CRISI DEGLI ANNI 2007-2009..COME POI, I MEGA RIALZI DELLE DUE ERE OBAMA..COME D'ALTRONDE AVEVA FATTO PER TUTTI GLI ANNI 90, IN BORSA, A MILANO..ALLORCHE' CREAVA MILIONI E MILIONI DI EURO, DA SOTTOZERO, OVUNQUE ANDASSE A LAVORARE..ERA DEFINITO ALLORA, COME LO STRA E', DA NOI, ORA: RE MIDA..FRA IL 1987 ED IL 1997, ALLORA GIOVANISSIMO, MICHELE, NONOSTANTE I VOSTRI BIECHI COMPLOTTI BERLUSCONAZISTI E PADANAZISTI, CREAVA ENORME VALORE, PER MILIONI E MILIONI DI EURO, OVUNQUE ANDASSE A LAVORARE (QUASI SEMPRE POSTI PICCOLI O MEDI, CHE RENDEVA DA SOLO, MEDIO-GRANDI O GRANDI..STILE VERONA DI BAGNOLI O CAGLIARI DI RIVA)..E DA SOTTO ZERO, DA SOLO, CONTRO TUTTO E CONTRO TUTTI..COSA CHE RI FA CON NOI ORA..SCRIVEVATE, D'ALTRONDE, TUTTO QUESTO, VOI STESSI, QUANDO LO MEGA SFRUTTAVATE E MOLTIPLICAVA I VOSTRI RISPARMI E CLIENTI, FRA IL 2007 ED IL 2009..ALLORA, PROFESSIONALMENTE PARLANDO, GLI DAVATE DEL GENIO OGNI GIORNO..MA AL COTEMPO, GLI MANCAVATE PURE DI RISPETTO IN MANIERA CRIMINALISSIMA, COME DA OVVI ORDINI DI VOSTRO STRAGISTA SPAPPOLA MAGISTRATI SILVIO BERLUSCONI DA "ARCORE-HARDCORE")!
    VOLETE FAR PAGARE A MICHELE IL SUO AVER, CON AMMIRABILISSIMO DISPREZZO, NON VOLUTO, NON SOLO NON COLLABORARE, MA MANCO VOLUTO SENTIRE PARLARE OLTRE, A PROPOSITO DELL' IMBOSCARE UNA PRIMA PARTE DI SOLDI RUBATI DA LEGA LADRONA ( FAMOSI 60 MILIONI DI EURO) E DAL DILANIA CARNI DI GENTE PER BENE, SILVIO BERLUSCONI, COME PROPOSTOGLI DI PERSONA DAL FACCENDIERE CRIMINALISSIMO E GIA' VARIE VOLTE CONDANNATO AL CARCERE, PAOLO BARRAI, NEL 8.2009, A LONDRA ( E SPECIALMENTE, VOLETE CHE TACCIA SU QUESTO, MA NOI NON CI PIEGHEREMO AI VOSTRI VOLERI STILE " COSA NOSTRA INCRAVATTATA" MAI E STRA MAI). VOLETE FAR PAGARLI IL SUO AVER SEMPRE DENUNCIATO A PROPOSITO DELLE MEGE CONCENTRAZIONI DI POTERE DEL PEDOFILO SPAPPOLA MAGISTRATI: SILVIO BERLUSCONI!
    B)TANTO VERO CHE NON ESISTE UN PAESE OCCIDENTALE AL MONDO (MA IO DIREI CHE QUASI NON ESISTE UN PAESE AL MONDO AT ALL, CHE SIA OCCIDENTALE O MENO), OVE CHI E' TITOLARE DIRETTO O INDIRETTO O VIA PRESTANOME (VEDI BERLUSCONICCHIO URBANO CAIRO DI LA 7- RIZZOLI) DI POTER DITTATORIAL-MEDIATICO, POSSA ANCHE AVERE POTERE POLITICO. QUESTO E' VIETATISSIMO IN USA, IN CANADA, IN LATIN AMERICA, IN TUTTA EUROPA, IN OCEANIA, IN ASIA, IN AFRICA.


    ReplyDelete
  13. B)
    MICHELE HA SOLO FATTO NOTARE QUESTO. LO VOLETE MORTO DA DECENNI "PER L'AFFRONTO ANTI BERLUSCONAZISTA FATTO". SIETE SICARI ASSASSINI HITLERIANI, FRANCHISTI, SALAZARIANI, PINOCHETTIANI, MAFIOSI, CAMORRISTI, NDRANGHETISTI. SIETE STRAGISTI SPAPPOLA MAGISTRATI. SE UNO DICE LA MERA TRASPARENTE VERITA', SOTTO GLI OCCHI DI TUTTI, ECCO CHE SENTENZIATE I VOSTRI EDITTI BULGARI
    http://www.repubblica.it/online/politica/rainominedue/berlu/berlu.html
    DISTRUGGI LAVORO, CARRIERE E QUINDI VITA TOTALE! IN UN PAESE DI TANTE, TANTE, "TROPPISSIME" MIGNOTTE E SCHIAVI FASCIOMAFIOSI DI ADOLPH HITLER-SILVIO BERLUSCONI, OSSIA IL VOSTRO SANGUINARIO MANDANTE, IN TEMPI NON SOSPETTI, MENTRE LO STESSO SBAUSCIA PROSTITUTE MINORENNI DI ARCORE-HARDCORE, FACEVA SPAPPOLARE GIOVANNI FALCONE E PAOLO BORSELLINO AD INIZIO ANNI 90
    http://www.ilfattoquotidiano.it/2012/02/28/un-pentito-di-mafia-le-stragi-del-93-chieste-da-b-e-da-dellutri/194251/
    O MENTRE, FRA IL 2001 E 2006 E FRA IL 2008 E 2011, ORDINAVA DA PALAZZO CHIGI, LE DISARTICOLAZIONI DI VITE ALTRUI (QUANDO NON RESE SUO ZERBINO), DA EFFETTUARE ATTRAVERSO TRAUMI (ALIAS OMICIDI MASCHERATI DA FINTI INCIDENTI, SUICIDI O MALORI..
    http://www.pmli.it/sismicolpivanemiciberlusconi.htm
    ATTRAVERSO I QUALI IL SANGUINARIO ASSASSINO SILVIO BERLUSCONI FECE UCCIDERE GIORGIO PANTO, PAOLO ALBERTI, ADAMO BOVE, MICHELE LANDI, CORSO BOVIO, PIETRO SAVIOTTI, ALBERTO CAPERNA, ANDREA PININFARINA, FRANCESCO MASTROGIOVANNI, MICHELE LANDI, FEDERICO ALDROVANDI, STEFANO CUCCHI, RICCARDO MAGHERINI, MICHELE FERRULLI, GIUSEPPE UVA.. QUEST'ULTIMO SODOMIZZATO ED UCCISO IN QUESTURA A VARESE, URLANDOGLI " CREPA, COMUNISTA DI MERDA".. BASTARDISSIMI OMICIDI CHE AVETE RIPETUTO, QUASI, ANCHE CON CLEMENTINA FORLEO, IN OGNI CASO, CHE AVETE FATTO SI, CON I GENITORI DI CLEMENTINA FORLEO..PROPRIO COME FATTO CON IL PAPA' DI MICHELE..BASTARDISSIMI OMICIDI CHE AVETE RIPETUTO CON ALTRE MIGLIAIA E MIGLIAIA DI UOMINI E DONNE DI CUI NON SAPPIAMO.."REI" SEMPLICEMENTE DI ESSERE A VOI "ANTIPATICI" O DI NON ESSERE ESATTAMENTE TAPPETINI DEL VOSTRO KAPO' E CAPO MAFIA, ALIAS PEDOFILO STRAGISTA SPAPPOLA MAGISTRATI SILVIO BERLUSCONI STESSO) MICHELE "SI PERMISE" SEMPLICEMENTE DI DEFINIRE LA REALTA' DEI FATTI, VISIBILISSIMA AD OGNUNO, PER QUEL CHE ERA (MENTRE LA METASTASI DI DEMOCRAZIA, LIBERTA' E GIUSTIZIA, SILVIO BERLUSCONI, FACEVA DI TUTTO PER UCCIDERE MICHELE "PROFESSIONALMENTE E SOCIALMENTE"..MENTRE LA METASTASI DI DEMOCRAZIA, LIBERTA' E GIUSTIZIA, SILVIO BERLUSCONI, SI CREDA O MENO, GLI FACEVA UCCIDERE IL PADRE..MENTRE LA METASTASI DI DEMOCRAZIA, LIBERTA' E GIUSTIZIA, SILVIO BERLUSCONI, SI CREDA O MENO, FACEVA LO STESSO, A SEGUITO, CON MICHELE, "SOLO" 4 VOLTE..SE MICHELE NON ANDAVA A VIVERE ALL'ESTERO, ERA ORA, PER ASSASSINA MANO VOSTRA, SOTTO TERRA..O SCIOLTO CON L'ACIDO O DENTRO QUALCHE BLOCCO DI CEMENTO..E DA DECENNI E DECENNI). QUINDI, ORA, VOI CHE SIETE SCHIFOSI CAMERATA NAZISTI, NONCHE' SICARI MAFIOSI PER SILVIO BERLUSCONI, GLIELA VOLETE FAR PAGARE, SULLA BASE DI DISCREDITO BASATO SU MEGA BALLE. ANZI, SU PERFETTI ROVESCIAMENTI, E QUINDI OPPOSTI DELLA VERITA' (IL VERME STRAGISTA SILVIO BERLUSCONI E' COSA NOSTRA, E' SWASTIKA ASSASSINA, QUINDI, O SI E' SUOI DECEREBRATI CORROTTI YES-MEN O YES-ZOCCOLE O SI DEVE CREPARE, COME SEMPRE ACCADE CON I BIECHI OMICIDA E PAZZI TIRANNI COME LUI).
    IL TUTTO SULLA BASE DI RAGLIARE DEGLI ALTRI, QUELLO CHE SIETE SOLO ED ESCLUSIVAMENTE VOI: MALATI MENTALI, ASSASSINI, MEGA COCAINOMANI, LADRI, CORROTTI, TRUFFATORI, NAZISTI, RAZZISTI, KUKLUKKLANISTI, MAFIOSI, CAMORRISTI, NDRANGHETISTI, MEGA RICICLA SOLDI SUPER LERCI (OSSIA "BERLUSCONICCHI" DOC). PER FINIRE, GENIO BORSTISTICO ED EROE CIVILE MICHELE NISTA, IN VITA SUA, HA SOLO ED ESCLUSIVAMENTE SCRITTO SU 2 BLOGSPOTS CHE GLI FACEVATE HACKERARE DI CONTINUO, IN QUANTO TEMEVATE, COME TUTT'ORA STRA TEMETE, IL SUO INTUITO E FIUTO DI PLATINO ( VEDENTE SEMPRE ANCHE NEL BUIO PIU' PESTO).


    ReplyDelete
  14. C)
    MICHELE NISTA E' UN GRANDISSIMO UOMO. OLTRE CHE UN VINCENTISSIMO GENIO BORSISTICO. COME DETTO ALL'INIZIO. MENTRE VOI, ETERNAMENTE PIDUISTI, NAZIMAFIOSI ED ASSASSINI PAOLO BARRAI, PAOLO CARDENÀ, GIACOMO ZUCCO, FEDERICO IZZI, ELISA COGNO, PIERA CLERICO, MAURIZIO BARBERO, GIULIANO FERRARA, CLAUDIO CERASA, DANIELE MINOTTI, MATTEO SALVINI, MARINA BERLUSCONI, MARIO GIORDANO, PAOLO LIGUORI, ENNIO DORIS, MASSIMO DORIS, OSCAR DI MONTIGNY, FEDELE CONFALONIERI, SILVIO BERLUSCONI (E TOPAIE FASCIOMAFIOSE DI VOSTRO CONTORNO) SIETE FOTOCOPIE OMICIDA DEI TERRORISTI TAGLIA TESTE DELL'ISIS. SGOZZATE O METTETE SOTTO I CAMION CHIUNQUE NON SIA VOSTRO TAPPETINO. SIAN ESSI BAMBINI, ANZIANI, ZOPPI, CIECHI. SI SIA CHI SIA. SIETE PEGGIO DEI TERRORISTI ISLAMICI! SIETE DEI VERMINOSI ADOLPH HITLER ED AL CAPONE DEL WEB! MA ANCHE DELLA VITA DI TUTTI I GIORNI! E MOLTO MA MOLTO PRESTO AVRETE TUTTE LE RISPOSTE CHE MERITATE. QUALCHE GIORNO E VEDRETE COME ARRIVERANNO TUTTE. DA ME IN PERSONA E NON SOLO. NON VI FAREMO AMMAZZARE GENIO BORSTITICO ED EROE CIVILE MICHELE NISTA (GLI MINACCIATE MORTE O CERCATE DI INDURLO AL SUICIDIO OGNI GIORNO, VIA EMAIL E NON SOLO, SICARI EFFERATI, SANGUINARI, KILLER, STRAGISTI, MEGA COCAINOMANI, BERLUSCONAZISTI E PADANAZISTI CHE ALTRO NON SIETE)! NON VE LO FAREMO RENDERE NUOVO GIACOMO MATTEOTTI, COME TANTISSIMO BRAMATE DAL VOLER FARLO DIVENIRE. VERGOGNA, DISUMANI, EFFERATI, SPIETATI ASSASSINI!!!!
    ANTONY. CONSULTANT GOLDMAN SACHS.
    PS
    MIO PADRE E' INGLESE, MIA MADRE E' ITALIANA, SONO NATO E CRESCIUTO A LONDRA. IL MIO ITALIANO SCRITTO E PARLATO, QUINDI, NON E' DI CERTO PERFETTO. SPERO COMPRENDIATE EVENTUALI ERRORI DI DIVERSO TIPO.
    EMAIL DI MICHELE MICHELENISTA6@MAIL.COM - LONDON 00447939.508007
    TEXT ABOVE WRITTEN BOUT AN ABSOLUTE GENIUS ON MANAGING TO ADVANCE WITH FULL SUCCESS, ALL THE TIMES ( THING ABSOLUTELY PROOVABLE) WHERE WORLDWIDE CRIPTOCURRENCIES, CURRENCIES, STOCKS AND COMMODITIES GO: MICHELE NISTA. BUT ESPECIALLY, TEXT BOUT AN ABSOLUTE HERO, AN ABSOLUTE NEW GIACOMO MATTEOTTI: MICHELE NISTA. PERSECUTED SINCE 30 YEARS BY WHO REDUCED TO A MUSH, 2 EXTREMELY HEROICAL MEN AND MAGISTRATES ( GIOVANNI FALCONE AND PAOLO BORSELLINO): SILVIO BERLUSCONI! PERSECUTED SINCE 30 YEARS BY THE WORST CRIMINAL "WHILE WEARING A TIE" OF THE WHOLE WORLD AND OF ALL THE TIMES: SILVIO BERLUSCONI! PERSECUTED SINCE 30 YEARS BY A PRINCIPAL OF HUNDREDS AND HUNDREDS OF "MASKED" MURDERS AND DOZENS OF SLAUGHTERS: SILVIO BERLUSCONI! PERSECUTED SINCE 30 YEARS BY A MEGA MAFIA MONEY LAUNDERER AND IMMENSE PROTAGONIST OF ANY KIND OF FINANCIAL CRIME: SILVIO BERLUSCONI! PERSECUTED SINCE 30 YEARS BY A NAZIST DICTATOR, SINCE ALWAYS, BECOME ONE WITH COSA NOSTRA, CAMORRA, NDRANGHETA, CHINESE MAFIA, RUSSIAN MAFIA, ALBANESE MAFIA, RUMENIAN MAFIA, NORTH AMERICAN MAFIA, COLOMBIAN MAFIA: SILVIO BERLUSCONI! PERSECUTED SINCE 30 YEARS BY AN ABSOLUTELY ASCERTAINED PEDOPHILE: SILVIO BERLUSCONI! AND OBVIOUSLY, ALL HIS CORRUPTED NAZIMAFIOSI HIT MAN AND ASSASSINS!
    ANTONY. SENIOR CONSULTANT GOLDMAN SACHS.

    ReplyDelete

  15. E’ PEDOFILO ED ASSASSINO: DANIELE MINOTTI (FACEBOOK)! AVVOCATO ^SATA-N-AZISTA^ DI GENOVA, RAPALLO E SANTA MARGHERITA LIGURE (A DIRE "FURBASTRO" DI SUO FACEBOOK ACCOUNT)! VERME NEO PIDUISTA MEGA RICICLA SOLDI MAFIOSI! AGENTE SEGRETO IN COPERTO DI TIPO ASSASSINO! FINO A POCO FA...SGOZZAVA...(OLTRE CHE BAMBINI, CANI, GATTI E SERPENTI IN RITI SATANICI)... LA DEMOCRAZIA E LA LIBERTA', COI BASTARDI CRIMINALI UBALDO LIVOLSI...PAOLO BERLUSCONI...SILVIO BERLUSCONI...MARINA BERLUSCONI....GIULIO OCCHIONERO....FRANCESCA OCCHIONERO...PAOLO BARRAI...GIULIANO FERRARA...ANSELMA DELL'OLIO...CLAUDIO CERASA E...

    1

    E......E....E...... E' DAVVERO DA ARRESTARE SUBITO L'AVVOCATO ASSASSINO E PEDOFILO DANIELE MINOTTI DI GENOVA E RAPALLO! SI, E' DAVVERO DA ARRESTARE SUBITO L'AVVOCATO ASSASSINO E PEDOFILO DANIELE MINOTTI DI SANTA MARGHERISTA LIGURE ( A DIR DI SUO CRIMINALISSIMO FACEBOOK ACCOUNT, CRIMINALISSIMO, QUINDI, MOLTO PROBABILMENTE DEPISTANTE)! MASSONE NEOPIDUISTA LAVA CASH MAFIOSO! AGENTE SEGRETO DI TIPO OMICIDA!


    NON MOSTRATE MAI I VOSTRI FIGLI AL PEDOFIL-O-MOSESSUALE ASSASSINO DANIELE MINOTTI (AVVOCATO PERICOLOSISSIMAMENTE PEDERASTA DI GENOVA E RAPALLO, PURE SU FACEBOOK: OLTRE CHE MEGA LAVA CASH MAFIOSO, NAZIRAZZISTA, OLTRE CHE AGENTE SEGRETO IN COPERTO DI TIPO OMICIDA)! FACEVA PARTE DI SETTA DI LUCIFERINI INCULA BAMBINI CON I DEPRAVATISSIMI SATANISTI PAZZI GIULIANO FERRARA ED ANSELMA DEL'OLIO ( " PAZZI MA NON SCEMI", COME SI USAN DEFINIRE). OLTRE CHE CON L'ARRESTATO REGISTA PEDOFILO GIUSEPPE LAZZARI. IL GIA' TRE VOLTE IN GALERA PAOLO BARRAI DI CRIMINALISSIMA CRYPTOPOLYS, CRIMINALISSIMA EIDOO E CRIMINALISSIMO BLOG MERCATO "MERDATO" LIBERO. ED IL PARIMENTI NOTO PEDOFIL-O-MOSESSUALE CLAUDIO CERASA DI TWITTER ED IL FOGLIO... FOGLIO, SI, MA DA USARSI SOLO E SEMPRE PER PULIRSI IL C.LO SE SI E' SENZA CARTA IGIENICA (BUT OCHO..E' INFETTATO DI COSA NOSTRA, CAMORRA, NDRANGHETA, NAZISMO E NUOVA P2)! E VISTO CHE ABBIAMO CITATO COSA NOSTRA.. DETTO PEDERASTA PALERMITANO DI CLAUDIO CERASA E' AFFILIATO DA ANNI A COSA NOSTRA: FAMIGLIA CIMINNA, MANDAMENTO DI CACCAMO!

    LETS' GO NOW, LET'S GO, IAMM BELL, IA'!

    INCULA TANTI BAMBINI L’AVVOCATO PEDOFILO E NAZISTA DANIELE MINOTTI DI RAPALLO (PURE SU FACEBOOK)! NON MOSTRATEGLI MAI I VOSTRI FIGLI! RICICLA PURE MOLTI SOLDI MAFIOSI! E’ PURE UN AGENTE SEGRETO IN COPERTO DI TIPO ASSASSINO!

    VICINO AI PUZZONI TERRORISTI DI ESTREMA DESTRA, CREANTI NUOVE OVRA E GESTAPO, DI CARATTERE TECNOLOGICO E MILITARE, SCHIFOSI MASSONI NAZISTI, SCHIFOSI MASSO-NA-ZISTI UBALDO LIVOLSI, GIULIO OCCHIONERO E FRANCESCA OCCHIONERO (IL PRIMO DI CRIMINALISSIMA LIVOLSI-IAQUINTA & PARTNERS E CRIMINALISSIMA LIVOLSI AND PARTNERS..GLI ULTIMI DUE, ORA, IN GATTABUIA, SPERIAMO, AL PIU' PRESTO, RAGGIUNTI ANCHE DAL PRIMO, CHE HA IN GOPPA, NON PER NIENTE, GIA' UNA MEGA CONDANNA A GALERA PER IL FALLIMENTO FINPART
    http://www.romacapitale.net/politica/34-politica/14277-cyberspionaggio-da-renzi-a-monti-a-draghi.html
    http://www.pmli.it/articoli/2017/20170118_03L_Occhionero.html
    https://interestingpress.blogspot.pt/2017/01/lingegnere-e-la-maratoneta-la-rete-di.html
    http://www.ilpost.it/2017/01/11/inchiesta-cyberspionaggio-occhionero-roma/
    http://jenkins-ci.361315.n4.nabble.com/VERME-SCHIFOSO-UBALDO-LIVOLSI-OCCHIONERO-FININVEST-DOVREBBE-ESSERE-IN-GALERA-ORA-A-CIUCCIARE-IL-CAZZ-td4895912.html )
    COMPLIMENTI VIVISSIMI AL VERO UOMO DI STATO, AMMIREVOLISSIMO DOTTOR ROBERTO DI LEGAMI, CHE DAL SCHIFOSISSIMAMENTE NAZISTA E PRO COSA NOSTRA, NONCHE' PARTE DI VERMINOSA NUOVA P2, POLIZIOTTO VOMITEVOLMENTE BERLU-S-MAZZETTATO E BERLUS-C-ORROTTO FRANCO GABRIELLI, E' STATO DESTITUITO DAL PROPRIO LAVORO, IN QUANTO "SI E' AZZARDATO" A SALVARE LA DEMOCRAZIA!!!
    http://notizie.tiscali.it/cronaca/articoli/occhionero-massoneria-gabrielli/




    ReplyDelete
  16. 2
    VERGOGNA E STRA VERGOGNA, TRATTASI DI ENNESIMO SGOZZAMENTO DI VALORI CHE PUZZA TANTISSIMO DI SPAPPOLA GIOVANNI FALCONE E PAOLO BOSELLINO, COMPRATORE DI GIUDICI A GOGO, DITTATORE NAZISTA, MANDANTE DI DOZZINE DI STRAGI E CENTINAIA DI OMICIDI MASCHERATI, PERVERTITISSIMO PEDOFILO SILVIO BERLUSCONI. CHE DA ANNI, NON PER NIENTE, ORGANIZZA NUOVE OVRA E GESTAPO ASSASSINE, PRIMA COI BASTARDI ASSASSINI GAETANO SAYA E RICCARDO SINDOCA, POI COI BASTARDI ASSASSINI GIULIANO TAVAROLI ED EMANUELE CIPRIANI, POI COI BASTARDI ASSASSINI ROBERTO PREATONI, ERNESTO PREATONI E FABIO GHIONI, POI COI BASTARDI ASSASSINI "POMPINARO" PIO POMPA, NICOLO' POLLARI E MARCO MANCINI..CHE, MAI DA DIMENTICARE, INTENDEVANO AMMAZZARE CHI "OSASSE" ESSERE NON BERLUSCONICCHIO, VIA "DISARTICOLAZIONI DI TIPO TRAUMATICISSIMO": OSSIA OMICIDI, RIPETO OMICIDI, RIPETO OMICIDI...PUR SE MASCHERATI DA FINTI SUICIDI, MALORI, INCIDENTI
    http://www.veritagiustizia.it/old_rassegna_stampa/la_stampa_piano_traumatico_contro_la_sinistra.php
    http://www.societacivile.it/focus/articoli_focus/sismi4.html
    http://www.pmli.it/sismicolpivanemiciberlusconi.htm
    ED ULTIMAMENTE VIA BASTARDI ASSASSINI UBALDO LIVOLSI, PAOLO BARRAI, DANIELE MINOTTI, CLAUDIO CERASA, GIULIANO FERRARA, RENATO FARINA E SUO "POMPINARO" PIO POMPA....PER NON PARLARE DEI NAZIVERMI VITTORIO FELTRI, FRANCO BECHIS, PIETRO SENALDI, FAUSTO CARIOTI, FRANCESCA OCCHIONERO E GIULIO OCCHIONERO..ULTIMI DUE, ORA, IN CARCERE, SPERIAMO AL PIU' PRESTO, IN COMPAGNIA DI TUTTO IL RESTO CITATO DI QUESTA GANG HITLERIANA CHE PUZZA MARCISSIMAMENTE DI OVRA, GESTAPO E DINA DI AUGUSTO PINOCHET!
    TORNIAMO IN OGNI CASO, ORA, ALL'EFFERATO ASSASSINO DANIELE MINOTTI, PLEASE!

    SUA LA SETTA DI SATANISTI, ANZI, SUA LA SETTA DI SATA-N-AZISTI STUPRA BAMBINI, CON DENTRO IL PARI PEDERASTA GIULIANO FERRARA!

    E SPECIALMENTE IL PARI PEDERASTA INCULA BAMBINI CLAUDIO CERASA ( FIGLIO DI ALTRO NOTO PEDOFILO, IL GIORNALISTA CRIMINALISSIMO GIUSEPPE CERASA: PENSATE CHE QUESTA COPPIA DI PEDERASTA PADRE E FIGLIO HAN SCRITTO LIBRI PER DIFENDERE I NOTI PEDOFILI DI RIGNANO, SI, I PEDOFILI COMPARI DEL PEDOFILO SATANISTA GIANFRANCO SCANCARELLO DI CANALE 5, I PEDOFILI COMPARI DEL PEDOFILO SATANISTA MAURIZIO COSTANZO DI CANALE 5, I PEDOFILI COMPARI DEL PEDOFILO NUMERO UNO AL MONDO: SILVIO BERLUSCONI)! NATO A PALERMO, AFFILIATO MAFIOSO DA ANNI (AFFILIATO MAFIOSO DA ANNI E PER QUESTO POSTO IN GOPPA AL FOGLIO..FOGLIO DA USARE PER PULIRSI IL CULO..BUT OCHO..E' INFESTATO DI NEONAZISMO, P2 E MAFIE DI MEZZO MONDO..POSTO IN GOPPA AL FOGLIO DALL'EDITORE DI COSA NOSTRA NUMERO UNO AL MONDO, SILVIO BERLUSCONI..IL VISCIDO TOPO DI FOGNA E NOTO PEDOFILO CALUDIO CERASA, E' "PINCIUTO DA PIU' DI DIECI ANNI, DA PIU' DI DIECI ANNI E' PARTE, DELLA FAMIGLIA MAFIOSA MEG-A-SSASSINA DEI CIMINNA, MANDAMENTO DI CACCAMO..ED E' STATO POSTO IN GOPPA AL FOGLIO, POI, IN QUANTO AMANTE OMOSESSUALE DI GIULIANO FERRARA..E ABBIAMO ANCHE PARECCHIE FOTO A PROPOSITO).

    COME PURE IL PARI PEDERASTA PAOLO BARRAI DI CRIMINALISSIMA EIDOO SVIZZERA, CRIMINALISSIMA CRYPTOPOLIS SVIZZERA, CRIMINALISSIMA BLOCKCHAIN INVEST SVIZZERA, CRIMINALISSIMA BIGBIT SVIZZERA, CRIMINALISSIMA WMO SAGL LUGANO, CRIMINALISSIMA WORLD MAN OPPORTUNITIES LUGANO, CRIMINALISSIMA WMO SA PANAMA, CRIMINALISSIMA BSI ITALIA SRL DI VIA SOCRATE 26 A MILANO, CRIMINALISSIMO BLOG MERCATO LIBERO ALIAS "MERDATO" LIBERO (SU CUI TROVATE TUTTO, QUI https://it-it.facebook.com/public/Truffati-Da-Paolo-Barrai). ED IL PARI PEDERASTA STEFANO BASSI DI TORINO E DE IL GRANDE BLUFF
    https://twitter.com/grandebluff
    https://it-it.facebook.com/stefano.bassi.758 TUTT'UNO CON LA NDRANGHETA E DA DECENNI. CINTURA FRA GLI ASSASSINI CALABRESI BASATI IN PIEMONTE ADOLFO CREA E ALDO COSIMO CREA http://www.torinotoday.it/cronaca/operazione-big-bang-ndrangheta-torino-arresto-adolfo-aldo-cosimo-crea.html ED IL "FORSE GIA' CITATO", BEN NOTO SPAPPOLA MAGISTRATI E SIMIL PEDERASTA SILVIO BERLUSCONI.

    ReplyDelete
  17. 3
    PER NON PARLARE DEL PARI PEDOFILO INCULA BAMBINI E MEGA RICICLA SOLDI MAFIOSI PAOLO CARDENA' RESIDENTE A PENNA SAN GIOVANNI (MACERATA), VIA UMBERTO I, NR 41, DI CRIMINALISSIMA CARDENA' CONSULTING DI VIA MONTESSORI 6, 63837 FALERONE (FM) - Tel: 0734.710786 E CRIMINALISSIMO BLOG VINCITORI E VINTI (SEMPRE A LAVARE CASH ASSASSINO, DI MAFIA RUSSA, NON PER NIENTE, INSIDIATASI NELLE MARCHE, COME PRIMO LUOGO AL MONTO, PER LAVARE SOLDI KILLER, COME PURE, SEMPRE A LAVARE SOLDI ALTRETTANTO ASSASSINI, SPECIE DEI MAFIOSI CRISAFULLI DI MILANO)
    https://it.linkedin.com/in/paolo-carden%C3%A0-6a610827
    ED IL PARI PEDERASTA E MEGA RICICLA SOLDI DI COSA NOSTRA E NDRANGHETA, ROCCO TRIPODI DI CRIMINALISSIMA HYPO TIROL BANK PARMA..E DI NAZISTA CASA POUND
    http://it.viadeo.com/it/profile/rocco.tripodi
    https://www.facebook.com/Rocco-Tripodi-1537588826544365/
    CHE INSIEME AL PARI PEDERASTA E MEGA RICICLA SOLDI, PURE DI NDRANGHETA, ANDREA BENETTON DI CRIMINALISSIMA EIDOO, CRIMINALISSIMA DIGITAL IDENTITY, CRIMINALISSIMA BHB NETWORK GMBH
    https://ch.linkedin.com/in/andbene
    E' TUTT'UNO CON LA IMMENSAMENTE ASSASSINA COSCA PESCE DI GIOIA TAURO, CHE DA GIOIA TAURO SBARCA TONNELLATE DI COCAINA OGNI MESE
    DI STA TOPAIA FASCIOMAFIOSA FACEVAN PARTE IN PIENO E STRA PIENO, IL PEDERASTA E MEGA RICICLA SOLDI DI STIDDA E COSA NOSTRA, DELINQUENTE ESTREMISSIMO RICCARDO CASATTA DI MALAVITOSA ETERNITY WALL E MALAVITOSA BLOCKCHAINLAB
    https://it.linkedin.com/in/riccardocasatta
    ED IL, NOTO A LONDRA COME " THE CRIMINAL BEAST", ALTRO VERME MALAVITOSISSIMO: THOMAS BERTANI DI ORACLIZE
    https://uk.linkedin.com/in/thomasbertani
    UNA DELLE PRINCIPALI LAVATRICI DI CASH KILLER DI MAFIA, CAMORRA, NDRANGHETA ED ALTRE GANGS ASSASSINE DI MEZZO MONDO. NELLA CITY LONDINESE I DUE PONGONO A DISPOSIZIONE DI KILLER SU KILLER, I MEGA LAVA CASH MAFIOSO SISTEMI BLOCKCHAIN E BITCOIN
    http://www.ilsole24ore.com/art/commenti-e-idee/2017-01-24/bitcoin-riciclaggio-invisibile-mafie-e-terrorismo-internazionale-164825.shtml
    PARTE DELLA NAZIGANG E' IN STRA PIENO IL BASTARDO FASCIORAZZISTA E MEGA RICICLA SOLDI MAFIOSI, GIACOMO ZUCCO DI CRIMINALISSIMA BHB NETWORK, CRIMINALISSIMA BLOCKCHAINLABIT, CRIMINALISSIMA BHB-BLOCKCHAINLAB, CRIMINALISSIMA ASSOB.IT E CRIMINALISSIMA, GIA' CITATA, WMO SA PANAMA (OLTRE CHE PRIMA MENZIONATI KU KLUK KLANISTI, NAZIRAZZISTI TEA PARTIES).
    TRATTASI DI ALTRO CIUCCIA CAZZI MORTI DI SILVIO BERLUSCONI, CON GRAVISSIMI PRECEDENTI PENALI ( QUI IN UN PROCESSO A PROPOSITO DI SOLITI BASTARDISSIMI CRIMINI DEL PEDOFILO SPAPPOLA MAGISTRATI SILVIO BERLUSCONI E SUA DIARREA CRIMINALISSIMA GUIDO PODESTA' https://www.radioradicale.it/scheda/397502/processo-a-guido-podesta-ed-altri-per-falso-ideologico?i=271737 ).
    CHE, PER LO STESSO PEGGIORE CRIMINALE IN CRAVATTA DI TUTTO IL MONDO E DI TUTTI I TEMPI, SILVIO BERLUSCONI, MEGA RICICLA SOLDI KILLER DI BEN 7 NDRINE BASATE NEL MILANESE (FRA CUI LA MEGA SANGUINARIA NDRINA DI SANTO PASQUALE MORABITO). COME DELL'EFFERATO KILLER CAMORRISTA SALVATORE POTENZA!

    DI STA TOPAIA MALAVITOSA FA PARTE IN STRA PIENO IL VERME CALABRESE TUTT'UNO CON LA NDRANGHETA, AFFILIATISSIMO A MEGA ASSASSINE NDRINE DI SINGEN (D) E FRAUNFELD (CH), PORCO CRIMINALISSIMO NATALE MASSIMILANO FERRARA O PORCO CRIMINALISSIMA NATALE FERRARA CHE SIA, DI GIA' CITATA DELINQUENZIALE EIDOO, CDELINQUENZIALE DIGITAL IDENTITY SA E DELINQUENZIALE BLOCKCHAIN INVEST. SCAPPATO IN SVIZZERA, IN QUANTO TEMEVA MANETTE DI PM ANTI MAFIA DI TIPO CALABRESE
    AND THEN AGAIN AND AGAIN AND AGAIN...
    FAN PARTE DI QUESTA GANG NAZINDRANGHETISTA, IL PARI PEDERASTA MAURIZIO BARBERO DI TECHNOSKY MONTESETTEPANI E ALBA
    https://twitter.com/mlnews_com?lang=es

    (CHE ERA CIO' CHE UNIVA IL BASTARDO HITLERIANO GIULIO OCCHIONERO AD ENAV, DI CUI, NON PER NIENTE, TECHNOSKY MONTESETTEPANI, SOCIETA' CONTROLLATA DA SERVIZI SEGRETI DI ESTREMA DESTRA, SPESSISSIMO ANCHE ASSASSINI, E' IN PIENO, PARTE).

    ReplyDelete
  18. 4
    ED IL NOTO RICICLA SOLDI MAFIOSI, MOSTRUOSO DELINQUENTE MATTEO PARDU DI MALAVITOSO STUDIO DI COMMERCIALISTI DEL SOLDATO DI LA SPEZIA!
    https://it.linkedin.com/in/matteo-pardu-90658820
    ED ANCORA, DELLA FASCIOMAFIOSA GANG ERA PARTE LA NOTA SATANISTA PEDOFILA ELISA COGNO DI FONDAZIONE FERRERO E FRUIMEX SAS ALBA E TORINO.
    https://www.impresaitalia.info/mstdb80753147/fruimex-di-cogno-elisa-e-c-sas/alba.aspx
    https://www.radioradicale.it/scheda/293882/imprese-e-politica?i=640046
    E LA NOTA PEDOFILA, TANTO QUANTO, PIERA CLERICO DI FRUIMEX SAS ALBA E TORINO ( SUA ZOCCOLISSIMA MADRE).
    https://it.linkedin.com/in/piera-clerico-77793388
    ENTRAMBE INDAGATISSIME DA VARIE PROCURE PIEMONTESI, IN QUANTO IDEATRICI E ORDINANTI TANTI OMICIDI E SPARIZIONI DI MATRICE SATANISTA, AVVENUTI NEL CUNEENSE
    http://www.ilfattoquotidiano.it/2013/05/29/piemonte-5-ragazzi-suicidi-in-sette-anni-pm-indagano-sullombra-delle-sette-sataniche/608837/
    AND THERE WE GO AGAIN AND AGAIN: DELLA "SATANAZISTA" GANG E' STRA PARTE IL PARI PEDERASTA, SEMPRE AZZERANTE I RISPARMI DI TUTTI: FEDERICO IZZI "TRADER" DETTO "ZIO ROMOLO ( CHE SBAGLIA IN BORSA, COME MINIMO, 11 VOLTE SU 10, E CAMPA SOLO E SEMPRE RICICLANDO CASH ASSASSINO DEI GIRI LERCI DI MAFIA CAPITALE E DI CAMORRISTI PRESENTI NEL BASSO LAZIO
    https://meloniclaudio.wordpress.com/2016/12/30/la-camorra-a-roma-e-nel-lazio/
    http://www.adnkronos.com/fatti/cronaca/2016/03/04/blitz-contro-camorra-nel-casertano-nel-basso-lazio-arresti_Ee3CRNYmUmhxiTgmJJK3kI.html )".
    PER NON DIRE DEL NOTO PORCO INCULA BAMBINI E MEGA RICICLA CASH MAFIOSO ANDREA SCARSI DI BANCA IFIGEST MILANO
    https://it.linkedin.com/in/andrea-scarsi-67a04a9
    FIGLIO DI NOTISSIMO GINECOLOGO PEDERASTA E SATANISTA ALESSANDRO SCARSI DI LATINA, CHE AMMAZZAVA BAMBINI SU BAMBINI PER LEVARGLI ORGANI DA VENDERE, CHE STUPRAVA E FACEVA ABORTIRE PROSITUTE MINORENNI ALBANESI A GOGO E CHE PER TUTTO QUESTO E’ FINITO IN GALERA
    http://www.telefree.it/news.php?op=view&id=2285
    https://groups.google.com/forum/#!topic/it.hobby.fai-da-te/V_4dMdeCZQA

    ReplyDelete
  19. 5
    PER NON PARLARE DEI PRIMA CITATI…
    NOTA PEDOFILA ANSELMA DEL’OLIO (SPOSATA COL MERDONE NAZISTA, MAFIOSO, CAMORRISTA, NDRANGHETISTA, PEDOFIL-O-MOSESSUALE SATANISTISSIMO GIULIANO FERRARA, CHE QUI AMMMETTE LUI STESSO CHE AMA BERE IL SANGUE DI CHI FA AMMAZZARE https://www.nuovaresistenza.org/2013/06/ferrara-horror-berro-il-sangue-di-chi-esulta-alla-condanna-di-berlusconi-articolotre-quotidiano-online-indipendente-e-di-inchiesta/ VIA SUOI COMPARI NAZIRAZZISTI DELLA CIA, PER CUI TRAMA DA DECENNI, SE COSTORO NON SONO TAPPETINI MERDOSI DI DELLO STRAGISTA SPAPPOLA MAGISTRATI E PEDOFILO PROPRIO COME GIULIANO FERRARA, DANIELE MINOTTI, CLAUDIO CERASA, MAURIZIO COSTANZO E GIANFRANCO SCANCARELLO: SILVIO BERLUSCONI). ED IL GIA’ ARRESTATO PER AVER STUPRATO BAMBINI DI 11 ANNI, REGISTA BRESCIANO PEDERASTA GIUSEPPE LAZZARI!!!
    http://milano.repubblica.it/cronaca/2016/08/09/news/pedofilia-145677361/
    NON PER NIENTE… FRA ANSELMA DELL’OLIO E GIUSEPPE LAZZARI, VI FURONO MOLTE SLINGUATE “PEDOFILESCO-MEDIATICHE”, NEGLI ULTIMI ANNI, TIPO QUESTA
    http://video.corriere.it/sesso-11enne-arrestato-regista-giuseppe-lazzari-l-intervista-rai/4287e44c-5e41-11e6-bfed-33aa6b5e1635
    MA ORA… COME CANTAVA LA GRANDISSIMA LYNN COLLINS, PRODOTTA DALL’ANCORA PIU’ GRANDE JAMES BROWN…
    "AGAIN AND AGAIN AND AGAIN"!!!
    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wB5KgOXHcxc
    NASCONDETE I VOSTRI FIGLI, PLEASE, DA NOTO AVVOCATO PEDOFIL-O-MOSESSUALE DANIELE MINOTTI (FACEBOOK)!
    NOTISSIMO AVVOCATO PEDERASTA INCULA BAMBINI DANIELE MINOTTI DI RAPALLO, GENOVA E SANTA MARGHERITA LIGURE, A LEGGERE SUO PALLONARO FACEBOOK ACCOUNT. DA ANNI ISCRITTO PRESSO GLI ANIMALI PAZZI CHE STUPRANO ADOLESCENTI E BIMBI, OSSIA I PORCI DEPRAVATISSIMI DI " ORGOGLIO PEDOFILO"
    http://www.today.it/rassegna/giornata-orgoglio-pedofilo.html
    E' SUA LA SETTA DI SATANISTI STUPRA BIMBI CON DENTRO IL REGISTA, PURE PEDOFILO, GIUSEPPE LAZZARI (ARRESTATO), LA NOTA PEDOFILA TANTO QUANTO, ANSELMA DELL'OLIO ( CHE, COME AVETE VISTO E RI VEDRETE IN UN VIDEO QUI A SEGUITO, DA' DEL GENIO, DA' DEL FENOMENO, DI CONTINUO, AL SUO COMPARE DI ORGE SODOMIZZA RAGAZZINI: GIUSEPPE LAZZARI).
    ED IL, NOTORIAMENTE, DA SEMPRE PEDOFIL-O-MOSESSUALE GIULIANO FERRARA! COME IL PEDERASTA AFFILIATO A COSA NOSTRA, IL VISCIDO VERME CLAUDIO CERASA, NATO A PALERMO IL 7.5.1982, PARTE DELLA FAMIGLIA MEGASSASSINA CIMINNA DI CACCAMO. E PROPRIO IN QUANTO PARTE DI COSA NOSTRA E DA VARI ANNI, POSTO DAI, DA SEMPRE EDITORI TANTISSIMO ALTRO A PROPOSITO, LO TROVATE QUI

    http://grokbase.com/t/python/python-list/148jckyh1w/avvocato-pedofilomosessuale-ed-assassino-daniele-minotti-facebook-oltre-che-nazi-megalava-euro-mafiosi-e-come-detto-mandante-di-omicidi-o-suicidate-stalker-di-eroe-civile-michele-nista-su-ordine-di-tiranno-fasciocamorrista-silvio-berlusconi

    ReplyDelete